Showing posts with label polygamy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label polygamy. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

DOMA's Constitutionality Will Now Be Tested

In a surprise to everyone involved in lawsuits regarding gay marriage, on February 23 the United States Attorney General notified Congress that the Department of Justice, at the instruction of the President, would abandon its defense of a section of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) that is now under attack in several lawsuits in US federal courts. The section that is being challenged defines the term, "marriage," as "a legal union between one man and one woman" for all purposes of federal law, including such things as federal personnel benefits, Social Security awards, and tax laws. The result is that a person who is considered legally married to a same-sex spouse in a state like Massachusetts is not considered married for the purposes of federal law.

Although this section of DOMA is not being defended, federal agencies were told to enforce it until it is repealed or "the judicial branch renders a definitive verdict against the law's constitutionality."

How can the President of the United States legitimately direct the Attorney General not to defend the constitutionality of a statute that has been enacted by Congress? What will be the effects on the pending lawsuits that attack the statute as an infringement on equal rights?

The answer to the first question is not as simple one might think. It is true that the US Constitution requires an oath from the President that he will "to the best of my Ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States." (Article II, end of Section 1.) Take note that it is the Constitution that the President is sworn to "preserve, protect and defend," not every statute that Congress may enact.

Later, the Constitution requires the President to "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." (Article II, Section 3.) It would seem that faithful execution of the laws would require the President to defend duly-enacted statutes in court. But one must remember that under the American system, the Constitution serves as the ultimate law, and a statute that conflicts with the Constitution is invalid. The faithful execution of the laws, therefore, sometimes requires a President to ignore a statute in order to uphold the Constitution when the two are in conflict.

While it is rare for a President to do this, in modern times Presidents of both parties have done so. A memorandum prepared for the Counsel to the President in 1994 during the Clinton Administration is available that lists some examples. (Its author, now in private practice in Washington, defended President Obama's action in Sunday's New York Times.) One may also examine the 1946 opinion of the Court in United States v. Lovett, which recounts how President Franklin D. Roosevelt refused to defend one portion of a law affecting federal employment, and that in INS v. Chadha (1982), indicating that the INS, a part of the Justice Department, refused to defend an immigration statute during the Carter and Reagan Administrations. In the presidency of George W. Bush, the Solicitor General informed the United States Senate by letter that the Department would not pursue an appeal of an adverse decision concerning a law forbidding the advertisement of marijuana on federally-funded mass transit.

But in most cases, the question of constitutionality is unclear, and there should be an able advocate to present the arguments in favor of constitutionality to the courts. It is troubling that President Obama has forbidden his Justice Department to do so when the appellate courts have not yet ruled. It is especially troubling that the President's conclusion on unconstitutionality depends on a "standard of review" that has not been adopted by any federal court to date in such cases.

The "standard of review" can make or break a case, for it determines how high a constitutional bar must be cleared to validate a law. Usually the "standard of review" is set high for alleged violations of fundamental rights and not so high for ordinary rights. The courts decide which rights are fundamental and what standard of review to apply. Under the highest standard, "strict scrutiny," applicable to such claims as race discrimination or violations of the First Amendment freedoms, statutes can rarely pass muster. Under the common standard, called the "rational basis" test, a law will often be upheld, because some sensible reason for the law is all that is required.

The reader will look in vain if he attempts to find these concepts in the text of the Constitution itself; they are inventions of twentieth century Supreme Court jurisprudence. In the past 50 years, the Court has taken contradictory positions on how it determines what rights deserve strict scrutiny to protect them and which are not. (Compare the opinions that upheld anti-sodomy laws in 1986 and invalidated them in 2004.) The decisions are complicated by an in-between status called "intermediate scrutiny." Race discrimination falls under strict scrutiny; sex discrimination comes under intermediate scrutiny; and discrimination against red-haired or left-handed persons receives only a check for a rational basis.

The President, perhaps recreating his salad days as a professor of constitutional law, has crafted a legal argument that intermediate scrutiny must be applied to DOMA. He says he cannot find any arguments powerful enough to sustain the law under that standard. This flies in the face of decisions in the First Circuit, where two of the DOMA appeals are pending, that indicate a rational basis standard of review is appropriate. In fact, there is no decision of an appellate court to date that adopts the President's opinion of the appropriate standard of review. In this respect, the legal basis of the President's action is highly questionable.

Also questionable are other aspects of the President's rationale. He assumes without any discussion that defining marriage discriminates against gays and lesbians because of their sexual orientation. But that is not at all obvious. People's right under Lawrence v. Texas to sexual activity of any orientation is not affected, in any form, under DOMA. Being married is beside the point. Many other types of devoted, loving couples are disqualified by DOMA from obtaining federal benefits: polygamists, close kin, and others who simply find a legal marriage to be irrelevant. Sexual orientation may not be the focus of what DOMA is about.

The President also relies on the immutability of sexual orientation. He says the alternative view, that it is capable of being changed, is refuted by "a growing scientific consensus." His only citation of authority for that claim is a book written by a federal appellate judge as a private individual. A review of the literature demonstrates that no such consensus exists. (1)

Moreover, it is wise to be very sceptical of social science research of any kind, for such research is often skewed by the biases of researchers, vague and poorly-worded surveys, lack of rigor in measuring cause and effect, sample selection biases, poorly-conceived research methods, and lack of sufficient sample sizes to provide acceptable confidence levels. In a related field, medical research, it has recently been found that over one-half of published studies reach erroneous conclusions because of poor research methods. Social science is notoriously more slippery than the physical sciences of medical research. If the research in the hard medical sciences cannot be relied upon, no one ought to put much confidence in social science studies of any type. (2)

Regardless of the weakness of his policy and legal analysis, the President's directive leaves the lawsuits without an advocate that will defend DOMA. What can be done to obtain such an advocate? It is not completely clear, but past precedent is somewhat encouraging. In INS v. Chadha, the Court of Appeals invited the Senate and the House of Representatives to file briefs separately as amici curiae in order to obtain the benefit of advocacy in support of the provision that the Justice Department and INS would not defend. Apparently each house engaged an attorney and filed a brief in the Court of Appeals and the US Supreme Court. In the case, United States v. Lovett, both houses agreed to engage a special counsel to appear on behalf of Congress in the trial court and then on appeal. In the DOMA cases, perhaps the House of Representatives can engage counsel for that purpose by itself, for it is unlikely that the Senate will go along.

In the alternative, the federal courts may allow Congress to enter the case as a party when the Justice Department bows out. The Court in Chadha commented, "We have long held that Congress is the proper party to defend the validity of a statute when an agency of government, as a defendant charged with enforcing the statute, agrees with plaintiffs that the statute is inapplicable or unconstitutional" (462 US 919, 940). If the Senate and House reach differing conclusions on whether such defense is advisable, is this precedent sufficient to allow one house to intervene? No one knows.

It would not be seemly for the federal courts to deny one house of Congress the right to defend a federal statute. American jurisprudence relies upon adversarial presentations to reach sound conclusions, and this is an important constitutional issue that will affect society in a fundamental way.

It is not likely that the courts will allow private parties to intervene for the purpose of defending DOMA, "because a private party whose own conduct is neither implicated nor threatened by a criminal statute has no judicially cognizable interest in the statute's defense, . . ." (Diamond v. Charles, 476 US 54, 56 (1986)).

Assuming that a defender comes forth, it is likely that he or she will present a stronger case in defense of DOMA than the Administration was presenting. The Attorney General admitted that the Administration had abandoned the grounds that Congress itself cited in support of DOMA. Supporters of family organizations doubted that this Administration would zealously defend the law.

If lawyers for Congress can now enter the cases, the President may even have done the defenders of DOMA a favor. Peter Wolfgang, executive director of the Family Institute of Connecticut, thinks so. "If anything, this increases the chances of the traditional marriage side,” says Wolfgang, because it will allow the real advocates of traditional marriage to fight and have a voice. Supporters of families may end up thanking President Obama for taking the Government out of the fight if it leads to a better defense of the law than his Administration was providing.


James S. Cole graduated from Harvard Law School and practices law in St. Louis, Missouri.

Notes
(1) One need only peruse such works as "Marriage and the Law: A Statement of Principles" by over 100 eminent legal and social science scholars, beginning with Mary Ann Glendon, Professor at Harvard Law School and Jean Bethke Elshtain, Laura Spelman Rockefeller Professor of Social and Political Ethics, University of Chicago Divinity School (Institute for American Values et al., 2006); M. Gallagher and J. Baker, Institute for Marriage and Public Policy, "Do Mothers and Fathers Matter? The Social Science Evidence on Marriage and Child Well-Being (2004); and The Witherspoon Institute, "Marriage and the Public Good: Ten Principles" (2006) for representative studies and results.

(2) J. Ioannidis, "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False," PLoS Med 2(8) (2005); D. Freedman, "Lies, Damned Lies, and Medical Science," The Atlantic, November, 2010.


This article is published by James S. Cole, and MercatorNet.com under a Creative Commons licence.

Thursday, June 3, 2010

Obama Acts for Partner Benefits

Obama on Wednesday directed federal agencies to immediately begin allowing domestic partners and their children some of the same rights available to spouses and children of employees. That includes child-care services and subsidies, expanded family and medical leave and relocation and other benefits.

Obama's memorandum covers only benefits that can be extended under existing law, without congressional action.

Read it all here.

Unmarried couples, homosexual partners, and polygamists are rejoicing.  But who is going to pay?

Friday, February 26, 2010

Most Pakistani Leaders are Polygamists

ISLAMABAD: The Minister of State for Ports and Shipping, Nabil Gabol, stunned the National Assembly on Thursday when he claimed that 80 per cent members of the house had more than one wife.

He said: “It should be left for Ulema to issue a decree whether anyone can have more than one wife or not”.

Interestingly, he was responding to a statement of his own party’s former information minister, Sherry Rahman, who contended that a man was not allowed to enter into second wedlock without permission from his first wife.

The surprising aspect of Mr Gabol’s claim was that no member in a thinly attended house, including any of the ministers, chose to deny or confirm his assertion.

Maulana Abdul Malik, a member from Fata, however supported Mr Gabol’s stance on polygamy by reciting a verse from Holy Quran: “Faithful are allowed to wed twice, thrice or four times provided they can maintain justice between wives.”

Ms Sherry referred to a recent statement of PML-Q’s women MPA in the Punjab Assembly in which she claimed that a Muslim man can have more than one wife without getting permission from his first wife.

She expressed her concern over the silence of the Punjab government as well as the federal government over the issue.

She said the Jamiah Al Azhar of Egypt had issued a decree (fatwa) that no one was allowed to indulge into polygamy under the prevailing circumstances.

From here.

Monday, December 21, 2009

Marriage Law to Change in Kenya

15 December - The Kenya Law Review Commission has urged the government to adopt the draft Marriage Bill of 2007, under which couples will not have to pay dowry to get married if the Bill is passed by Parliament into law.

The Deputy Chairperson of the Commission, Nancy Baraza, said the current marriage laws do not take into account African customs and traditions.


The other bills include the Matrimonial Property and the Domestic Violence (Family Protection) Bill 2007.


“The old archaic English law is procedural. It never gave us substantive law for example to define what matrimonial property is, so the draft Matrimonial Property Bill 2007 kills that deficiency,” she stated.


The drafts were set aside by the Cabinet a month ago to facilitate debate on the contentious clauses.


Local reports said marriages would be considered a complete contract irrespective of the dowry, they further state that persons who choose to marry under the customary law may still opt to pay dowry.


If the Marriage Bill becomes law, the institution of marriage in Kenya will undergo radical changes.


Analysts said the new amendments are bound to trigger protests, raise eyebrows and elicit sighs of relief or jubilation depending on how one interprets the proposed law.


Clauses likely to spark controversy are those that recognise polygamous marriages, outlaw mandatory payment of dowry and one that provides for either spouse to maintain the other in case of separation.

The Marriage Bill 2007 not only recognises polygamous unions but also provides for their registration.
Source:  Afrol News

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Belgium: Sharia Everyone?

It is hot in Brussels. Ramadan has begun. The faithful in the predominantly Muslim borough of Molenbeek are not allowed to eat or drink from sunrise until sunset. Non-Muslim policemen, patrolling the streets of Molenbeek in their sweltering cars, are not allowed to eat or drink either. As every year during Ramadan, that they have been told by their superior, Philippe Moureaux, the Socialist mayor of Molenbeek, they have to respect Muslim sensitivities and not to “provoke” Muslims by violating Islamic Ramadan restrictions in public. In effect, Islamic or Sharia law is already applied - for everyone - in the Muslim areas of Brussels.

Barely two miles from Molenbeek lies Brussels’ European district. One of its huge glass and concrete buildings is the European Parliament where the elected representatives from the 27 members states of the European Union (EU) convene. The 736 MEPs (Members of the European Parliament) have just returned from their summer break. They are mostly unaware of life in Molenbeek. Most of them never go to that part of the city. It is probably a sensible decision, because Molenbeek is known to be unsafe for non-Muslims. Nevertheless, it is a shame that Europe’s politicians are unaware of day-to-day life just around the corner. It means that most of the 736 MEPs, who make up the second largest democratically elected assembly in the world (after India), do not know what life really is like in an ever growing section of Europe’s urban areas. A walking tour of Molenbeek should be compulsory for every MEP.

Some friends in Brussels organize one-hour trips through Molenbeek. They go in an inconspicuous car, driven by a local who knows the escape routes, and with a bodyguard. Otherwise the risk would be too great. These trips are called “safaris.” Similar “Eurabia Safaris” are organized in other European cities. One of the highlights - though absolutely not the most dangerous one - of the safari in Rosengaard, the Muslim section of the Swedish city of Malmö, is a short stop, to give the visitor the opportunity to take a quick snapshot, in front of Malmö’s “Jihadskörkortsteori” (Jihad Driving School).

The Sharia areas of Europe are expanding rapidly across Western Europe. While currently still restricted to what the French officially call the ZUS (zones urbaines sensibles - sensitive urban areas) these areas are growing fast. Even today, eight million of the sixty million inhabitants of France already live in one of the country’s 751 ZUS.

The month of Ramadan is traditionally the most dangerous time of the year in Europe’s sensitive areas. After sunset, the Ramadan ban on eating, drinking and engaging in sexual activities expires until the following sunrise. Ramadan is a period of nightly feasts for Muslims. Young Muslims are extremely touchy. These feasts easily spill over into nightly spasms of mayhem, vandalism, and violence. Europe’s Ramadan riots often go on for days or weeks, during which hundreds of cars, shops and public buildings are set on fire.

In Muslim countries, such as Indonesia, the police step up patrols during Ramadan in order to crack down on illegal nightly activities. In Europe, however, the police have been given orders to adopt an extra-low profile not to “provoke” Muslim populations. In countries such as Britain, police officers have had to attend “Ramadan awareness” courses. They have even been ordered, “for reasons of religious sensitivity,” to avoid the execution of arrest warrants for Muslims during the month of Ramadan. During Ramadan, Europe is a tinder box.

The most widely reported Ramadan riots so far, which were even covered by the American press, took place in France in 2005. Since the 2005 riots, the French authorities have asked the media not to report about waves of violent unrest in the ZUS - a request which the media seem to have followed. During the 2005 Ramadan riots, several sociologists suggested that polygamy was one of the reasons for the large-scale rioting in Muslim communities among youths who lack a father figure. This theory seemed to have impressed France’s political leaders. Gérard Larcher, then France’s employment minister and currently the president of the French Senate, explained to the Financial Times (Nov. 15, 2005) that multiple marriages among immigrants lead to anti-social behavior, such as criminal activity. Bernard Accoyer, a leading parliamentarian of France’s governing UMP and currently the president of the French National Assembly (France’s Congress), said that children from large polygamous families have problems integrating into mainstream society.

As the Financial Times warned, however, at the time, “Mr Larcher’s comments could further fuel the debate and are likely to outrage Muslim and anti-racism groups.” Apparently, the French government was of the same opinion; it did not follow-up the words of Messrs. Larcher and Accoyer with a clampdown on polygamy. Having multiple wives is illegal under French law, but is allowed under Islamic Sharia law. It is estimated that 30,000 French Muslims have more than one wife and that more than 250,000 people live in polygamous families.

The tolerance of polygamous Sharia marriages is not restricted to France. In Norway, the Islamic Cultural Center Norway (ICCN), an immigrant organization subsidized by the Norwegian state, advises Muslims to take several wives because polygamy “is advantageous and ought to be practised where conditions lend themselves to such practice.” In Britain legislators adopt an equally liberal approach towards polygamy for Muslim men, allowing tax breaks for their second, third and fourth wives. Last February, Baroness Sayeeda Warsi, a Conservative Peer of Muslim origin, warned that the growing numbers of Muslim men marrying up to four wives in Britain, is becoming a threat to community cohesion. In the Netherlands, the authorities officially register polygamous marriages by non-Dutch citizens from Morocco, Egypt, Pakistan and other Muslim countries. The Amsterdam municipal authorities admitted that they have even registered Dutch citizens (of Islamic origin) with multiple wives. Belgium, too, recognizes polygamous Islamic marriages. Only last month, the welfare department of the city of Antwerp announced that 45 welfare recipients have two or more spouses.

Polygamous immigrants abuse the social security system by collecting state benefits for several wives. In France, residence is only granted to polygamous families if the two wives do not live at the same address, which means that these families claim double social housing, family allowances and other social benefits.

The recognition of polygamous marriages of Muslims in countries where polygamy used to be illegal - and still is illegal for non-Muslims - indicates that Sharia law is already accepted in these countries. They have implicitly accepted a system of “legal apartheid” with different legal systems for Muslims and non-Muslims. The decision to avoid arresting Muslims during Ramadan “for reasons of religious sensitivity,” thereby treating Muslims and non-Muslims differently, confirms this existence of a dual legal system. It is difficult to see, however, how such a dual legal system can continue to exist on the same territory. Ultimately, one of the legal systems is likely to prevail. The decision of the Molenbeek mayor that non-Muslim police officers have to respect the Ramadan prescriptions indicates what the next step will be if Europe’s authorities fail to impose the existing laws of the land on Islamic immigrants: the imposition of Sharia law on everyone, non-Muslims as well as Muslims. While Europe’s Muslims hold their Ramadan, this is something worth pondering for Europe’s non-Muslims.

From here.

Sunday, August 10, 2008

Cases of Polygyny Growing

Alice C. Linsley

Polygamy is against the law in the United States and rarely prosecuted, unless it involves sexual abuse of minors. The May 2008 intervention in the case of the Fundamentalist Church of the Latter Day Saints in Texas is about sex with minors, not polygamy. In fact, state officials in Utah, Arizona, and Texas are reluctant to prosecute polygamy cases. It means wading into religious waters and Constitutional challenges.

Polygamists find religious justification for polygamy in the Old Testament, although they clearly don't understand the tribal context that restricted the practice to rulers.

Afro-Asiatic chiefs maintained 2 wives in separate households on a north-south axis. These wives marked out the boundaries of the chief’s territory. Sometimes there were also concubines, but these women did not have the social status of the 2 wives. Abraham’s father, Terah, had 2 wives. By one wife he had Abraham and Nahor. By the other wife he had Sarah (Abraham’s first wife) and Haran. Abraham also had 2 wives: Sarah and Keturah. Isaac had 2 wives and so did Jacob. (For more on this read this.)

There is no evidence that all the men of Abraham’s culture had 2 wives. It appears to have been the case for the first born sons of rulers, those sons who would take over their fathers’ territories. So while there is no doubt that polygyny (multiple wives) was practiced by biblical figures, it was a custom of rulers, not the common man. It served to build up a man’s kingdom. And this is exactly what polygamist leaders in the US are attempting to do.

Read it all here.


Related Reading:  Polygamy More Common Than You Think

"Christian" Polygamy (Say What?)


"Polygamy is a lack of realization of sex; it is like a man plucking five pears in mere absence of mind."--G.K. Chesterton (The Ethics of Elfland)

Alice C. Linsley

Read the rationale at the Pro-Polygamy blog, here. Polygamy and Christianity simply do not go together, ask any Christian bishop living in countries where polygamy is practiced.

For clarification we are speaking of multiple wives, not multiple husbands. The technical term in this case is "polygyny" not polygamy. Polygamy refers to the practice of having multiple spouses and is not gender specific. Polygyny is the practice of multiple wives and that is the practice in question.

Polygyny is an ancient practice traced back to Africa. Among Abraham's Nilo-Saharan people only rulers had multiple wives. Terah, Abraham's father, had 2 wives. Abraham had 2 wives. Very likely Isaac had 2 wives, and Jacob had 2 wives.

The rulers among Abraham's people had only 2 wives and the wives lived in separate households geographically removed, and on a north-south axis. One wife was a half-sister and the other was a patrilineal parallel cousin.

In Africa, when a man's economic and social status increases he might take a second and even a third wife. Rarely does a man have more than 3 wives. The number 3 represents the ideal number because 3 first-born sons is regarded as a unity or a kingdom. That is why there are so many instances of 3 sons listed in the Hebrew Scriptures.

The Hebrew prophets criticized Solomon for having many wives and concubines. In doing so, Solomon departed from the marriage and ascendancy pattern of his Horite ancestors.

Wives and concubines have different legal and social status. Abraham had two wives (Sarah and Keturah) and two concubines (Hagar and Masek). This was the norm for Horite rulers.

The Church very early distanced itself from polygamy because it had become a way of seeking worldly status. Rulers or elders in the Church were strictly forbidden to have more than one wife.


Related reading: No, You can't take another wife!


Monday, July 21, 2008

Estate Law and Multiples Partners

Estate law in Canada is facing ramifications of same-sex partnerships, adoptions by homosexual couples, and polygamy. The legal landscape has become quite messy when it comes to determining what constitutes a legal partner. Does a cohabitation requirement of at least 3 years mean the partners must have been living under the same roof for the entirety of those 3 years? What about men who maintain multiple households?

Sean Graham has written at Toronto Estate Law Blog:

Estate planning and litigation professionals are still mulling over how the legalization of same-sex marriage will affect their practices. Even more complex developments may be in the offing.

An allegedly polygamist community in British Columbia and increased concerns about the possibility of polygamy elsewhere in all but name in other regions of the country raise any number of issues, not only of policy, but also estate planning.

For example, if someone dies leaving multiple spouses but only one legally-married spouse, what advantages would the legally-married spouse have over the others in the division of a contested estate?

How will the fact that bigamy and polygamy remain illegal play out in civil estate disputes?

If proscriptions on polygamy are or become ignored by governments, will the law evolve? And as it did in the case of same-sex marriage, what happens if bigamy or polygamy becomes legal, since families may become large enough that dependant’s support claims could exhaust most estates rendering much estate planning redundant?

Source: Hull and Hull LLP blog

For more on this go here.

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Polygamy: Spreading Silently

Alice C. Linsley

Polygamy is against the law in the United States and rarely prosecuted, unless it involves sexual abuse of minors. The recent intervention in the case of the Fundamentalist Church of the Latter Day Saints in Texas is about sex with minors, not polygamy. In fact, state officials in Utah, Arizona, and Texas are reluctant to prosecute polygamy cases. It means wading into religious waters and Constitutional challenges.

The religious justification for polygamy is found in the Old Testament. It was the practice for Afro-Asiatic chiefs to have 2 wives living in separate households on a north-south axis. These wives marked out the boundaries of the chief’s territory. Sometimes there were also concubines, but these women did not have the social status of the 2 wives. Abraham’s father, Terah, had 2 wives. By one wife he had Abraham and Nahor. By the other wife he had Sarah (Abraham’s first wife) and Haran. Abraham also had 2 wives: Sarah and Keturah. Isaac had 2 wives and so did Jacob. (For more on this subject read this.)

There is no evidence that all the men of Abraham’s culture had 2 wives. It appears to have been the case for the first born sons of rulers, those sons who would take over their fathers’ territories. So while there is no doubt that polygyny (multiple wives) was practiced by biblical figures, it was a custom of rulers, not the common man. It served to build up a man’s kingdom. And this is exactly what polygamist leaders in the US are attempting to do.

While state officials waffle in their thinking on the issue, polygamy silently spreads across the US among Moslems. According to a recent NPR report, Moslems in polygamous relationships number between 50,000 to 100,000. Legal challenges are avoided because only one of these marriages is officially recognized by the state. The other marriages are religious ceremonies not recognized by the state.

In many cases, Moslem men maintain wives in the US and in their homelands. These unofficial marriages are often secret, and the second and third wives are without legal rights or protections. There are many incidents of abuse by both the husband and his first wife. For more, read the NPR article here.